Amara Cay Resort

Our 3.5-Star classification designates those properties where guests experience an ideal mix of comfortable accommodations and modern amenities. Most of these hotels feature a variety of services, and offer distinguished style and comfort. Half star indicates that the hotel/resort meets all criteria of the designated rating and exceeds in certain areas.
Star Rating


Islamorada’s Amara Cay Resort is geared toward the never-miss-a-moment crowd. It’s for those who do more than appreciate life’s little moments; it’s for those who make the moment. It features rooms and suites decorated in the fresh, natural hues of Islamorada and infused with the easy elegance of the tropics. Enjoy a tropical cocktail or classic American cuisine at Tiki Bar, a breezy poolside spot, or an island favorite and fresh fish at ReelCatch. Start your day with a cup of coffee at Coastal Cup & Lounge, where you can also end your day with a cocktail. Amara Cay Resort also boasts an outdoor zero-entry pool, private beach, marina, state-of-the-art fitness center, and a gift shop.


80001 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL, USA 33036

Ideally located on beautiful Islamorada in the Florida Keys, 81 miles from Miami International Airport (MIA).

Hotel Amenities

  • Business Center
  • Front Desk
  • Gift Shop
  • Gym/Fitness Center
  • In Room Dining
  • Laundry Service
  • Meeting Facilities
  • Parking
  • Shuttle Service

Hotel Activities

  • Beach
  • Outdoor Pool

Room Amenities

  • Air Conditioning
  • Alarm Clock
  • Balcony or Patio
  • Bathrobe
  • Cable/Satellite TV
  • Coffee/Tea Maker
  • Flat Screen Television
  • Hairdryer
  • High Speed Internet Access
  • Iron and Ironing Board
  • Microwave

Hotel Dining

Tiki Bar – Serves classic American cuisine and tropical cocktails; ReelCatch – Offers island favorites and fresh fish.

Nearby Attractions

Theater of the Sea, Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park, Rain Barrel Village, History of Diving Museum, Keys History & Discovery Center, Shell Key, Robbie’s.

Book Now

Need Help?
Call us toll free at 1-800-742-9244